The Problem With Those ‘Feminist’ Super Bowl Ads - ads28.com :: Ads28 Online Advertisement

Today's Post

test banner

Post Top Ad

Responsive Ads Here

Post Top Ad

Responsive Ads Here

The Problem With Those ‘Feminist’ Super Bowl Ads



It was impossible not to notice that Super Bowl advertisers got feminism this year. The #LikeAGirl commercial was such an emotional call to consider the implications of casual sexism that we forgot Always was selling us maxi pads. The dad-centric ads from Dove and Nissan were the sort of thing that women, all too used to commercials that venerate motherhood as a higher calling, have longed to see.

There was an entire Nationwide ad based on Mindy Kaling saying she felt rendered invisible by sexism and racism. (Score one for intersectionality!) Then there was the NoMore.org spot, a PSA about domestic violence that was aired during the NFL's own allotted advertising time. “For feminism, those were the obvious wins — the ones that prompt a proverbial spiking of the football,” wrote Soraya Nadia McDonald at the Washington Post.

 I certainly prefer girls throwing punches and Mindy Kaling’s eye-rolls to the back-slapping boys'-club tone of GoDaddy and Budweiser ads from Super Bowls past. But this year’s empowerment-infused commercials left me feeling conflicted. Of course I endorse the idea that "girly" is not an insult, that being a dad is important work, that systemic injustice can render certain women invisible, that domestic-violence survivors deserve support not scorn. I want these ideas to go mainstream. So then why did I cringe watching companies use those ideas to sell stuff during the Super Bowl? It’s not because I’m an impossible-to-please feminist killjoy. (Though the NFL does tend to bring out that side of me.) It’s because most of the ads are hollow: soaring messages with few concrete policies or actions behind them. Modern feminist-tinged advertising — or “empowertising,” as Andi Zeisler calls it — works on two levels.

 It feeds our collective hunger for big cultural shifts, while simultaneously allowing corporations an easy way out of helping to make those shifts a reality. High in calories but low in nutritive value, to put it in Super Bowl snack terms. This year’s case in point is the domestic-violence PSA. It directs viewers to NoMore.org, a PR effort with no full-time staff that is bankrolled by a bunch of big companies. The site links to established nonprofit groups that do great work — like the National Domestic Violence Hotline, which received $5 million from the NFL in the wake of the Ray Rice incident.

But it's a convenient distraction from the fact that the NFL has not actually changed its policies on domestic violence, and has deftly avoided Congress's efforts to get it to step up. (The NFL even hired one of the architects of the Violence Against Women Act as a lobbyist to convince senators to drop the issue.) “The NFL has changed,” Deadspin reports, “but mainly in ways that promote its image, allow it to work with brands, and don't really do much to help anyone on the front lines of working with domestic-violence victims.”

 Slate declared last year “our first feminist Super Bowl.” It seems safe to say that 2014 was the first of many Super Bowls that will carry that title. But make no mistake: This isn’t companies waking up to feminism. It’s companies getting real about the fact that 46 percent of Super Bowl viewers are women, and pseudo-feminist ads grab their attention a lot better than traditional beer-commercial fare.

Women also out-tweet men. “Ads with female appeal = best return on $4 million price-tag,” wrote Kat Gordon at Adweek. That’s not merely because of women’s long-touted buying power. Women are more active on social media than men, and a heartfelt “experiment” in girls’ self-image or a loving shout-out to fatherhood is going to get a lot more of their tweets and Facebook shares than a woman eating a cheeseburger in a bikini.

“It’s great to see brands do something bigger with their Super Bowl ads,” a creative director told The Wall Street Journal. And I agree that dedicated dads and fierce-faced girls are better than beer-soaked sexism. But rather than feeling satisfied that these ads represent how far we’ve come, we should see them as an indication of how far we have to go. They open up a great opportunity to press the advertisers for details on how they’re putting their purported ideals into practice. How much of its annual profit is Always diverting to girls’ empowerment programs? What sort of paternity-leave policies are in place at Dove and Nissan — and do those companies support better federal family-leave laws for all parents? How is the NFL changing its policies, not just its messaging, toward players who abuse their partners?

The underlying problem for advertisers is that feminism doesn’t really work as a brand if that’s all it is. Once you bring people’s attention to these issues, they’ll start to notice when things don’t track. Just look at the cynicism that’s emerged regarding Dove’s “real beauty” ads. Nobody remembers “You’ve come a long way, baby” — the mother of all pseudo-feminist slogans deployed to sell products — as a cry of empowerment that ushered in an era of pay equity and financial freedom. We remember it as a cigarette company trying to get more women to light up. Therein lies a lesson for the corporations eager to gain women’s dollars and tweets with feminist-friendly Super Bowl ads. You wanted the attention of viewers like me? You got it. But now that you have it, don’t be surprised to hear that I have a few follow-up questions.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Domain for sale

Domain for sale
Networking (12) video (12) Dofollow Backlinks (9) Social Bookmarking Sites (9) Bookmarking Site (8) Free Directory List (8) google Adsense (8) marketing (8) Adsense Safe.Website Traffic (7) Authority Domains (7) EDU - GOV Backlinks (7) Web Directory Site (7) directory sites seo (7) Adsense (6) Domain (6) Sale Domain (6) ads28 (6) business (6) mlm (6) network (6) network marketing (6) whitehat backlinks (6) Online Dating (5) Page Rank Domain Sale (5) seo (5) Adsense ad units (4) Boost your Alexa (4) business networking (4) buy domain (4) internet marketing (4) Most famous Viral video (3) News (3) dating (3) marketing tips (3) referrals (3) Bank (2) Banks (2) Business/Job opportunity (2) Client Attraction Coach (2) Health Insurance (2) IRDA Grievance Call Centre (2) Leni Chauvin (2) Life Insurance (2) Most viewed YouTube videos (2) REAL Visitors (2) Sell PR Domains (2) Sell Premium Page Rank PR Domains (2) Usefull TollFree Numbers (2) Viral video on youtube (2) Website Traffic (2) Western Digital India Customer Care Number (2) adult dating online (2) buy twitter follower (2) customers (2) downline (2) godaddy (2) internet (2) marketing ideas (2) marketing strategy (2) money (2) professional development (2) sales (2) seo site (2) services (2) small business marketing (2) web traffic (2) Aadhaar Card (1) Aadhaar Card Toll Free Number (1) Agreement as valid Address Proof. (1) Apartment for Rent in burj khalifa (1) Apartment for sale in burj khalifa (1) Apartment in dubai downtown for rent (1) Asian Paints (1) Asian Paints Customer Care (1) BEST FUNNY NEWS (1) BLOOPERS 2016 (1) Backlinks (1) Beautiful Water Painting (1) Bharat Gas (1) Bharat Gas Customer Care Phone Number (1) Blank Space (1) Blog guest post (1) Blogger Website (1) Blogs (1) Bookmarking (1) Bookmarking service (1) Building (1) Business Website (1) Business group (1) Business organizations (1) Business-group (1) Business-organizations (1) CIBIL (1) CIBIL Customer Care (1) Carrier AC Customer Care (1) Chanakya IAS Academy (1) Chanakya IAS Academy Ahmedabad (1) Chanakya IAS Academy Coaching (1) Chanakya IAS Academy Hazaribagh (1) Chanakya IAS Academy Ranchi (1) Chanakya IAS Academy South Delhi (1) Chat (1) Click2Protect (1) Coach (1) Communication (1) Consumer Affairs Department (1) Consumer Helpline (1) Credit Information Bureau (1) Custom and Professional Blogger Website (1) Data Entry from home for money (1) Date (1) Dating Online (1) Deepak Bansal IPS - Success Speaks Episode 8 (1) Dell Customer Support (1) Desi (1) Do follow Social Bookmarking Sites (1) Dofollow Social BookMark (1) Domains (1) Ebay Customer Care (1) Ebay Customer Care India (1) Ebay Customer Care Number (1) Ebay Customer Care Number In India (1) Ebay Customer Complaints (1) Ebay Customer Service (1) Ebay Customer Support (1) FACEBOOK page LIKE (1) FIRST KISS (1) Facebook is a social networking (1) FedEx (1) FedEx Customer Care (1) Federal Bank Customer Care Number (1) Forums (1) Free Dating (1) Free Online Dating (1) Fujitsu Laptop (1) Gangnam Style (1) General Insurance (1) Get an edge (1) HDFC Life (1) HDFC Life Customers Service Number (1) HDFC Mutual Fund or Investment Services Account (1) HOW TO KISS (1) HOW TO KISS TUTORIAL (1) Health India TPA Services Toll Free number (1) Health Insurance TPA (1) Helpline Number at Amazon (1) High Authority Backlinks (1) Highlight your Service (1) Highlight your Service on seoclerks.com (1) Home Based Data Entry (1) IRDA Contact Number (1) IRDA Head Office (1) Indian (1) Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority IRDA Contact Number (1) Jab Harry Met Sejal Trailer (1) Kingson Dream (1) Kingson Dream Motivational Video (1) Know your business (1) LMFAO (1) Laugh (1) List of Non-Life Insurance Companies in India (1) List of Non-Life Insurance Companies in India (1) Listen (1) MLM Email Leads (1) MLM Lead Generation (1) MLM Leads (1) MLM Leads List (1) Man (1) Mangalayatan University Customer Care (1) Mediclaim TPA (1) Meeting friends (1) Men (1) Millionaire (1) Millionaire Dating (1) Millionaires (1) Mini Desktop Computer (1) Motivational Video (1) Myspace (1) PR Backlinks (1) Pagerank Backlinks (1) Pakistani (1) Passport Seva (1) Passport Seva Customer Care Number Toll Free (1) Paypal Customer Care‎ (1) Paypal India Customer Care‎ (1) Paypal India Customer Care‎ : 1800-212-3852 (1) Picture rating (1) Pizza Hut 50% Off Pizza Coupons‎ (1) Pizza Hut Buy 1 Get 1 Pizza Free‎ (1) Pizza Hut Coupons Promo Coupon (1) Pizza Hut Flat 50% Off Coupon‎ (1) Psy (1) RDP Mini PC (1) Registered Rent Agreement as valid Address Proof (1) Results (1) Rich (1) Rich Dating (1) Rich Men Dating (1) SBI NRI Services (1) SMS (1) SWIFT Code (1) SWIFT Code of SBI (1) Sell Buy (1) Sell Page Rank Domains (1) Selling (1) Small PC (1) South Asian (1) Stock Broker (1) Success (1) TP LINK India Customer Care Number (1) TPA For Mediclaim (1) TPA Health Services (1) TUTORIAL (1) Taylor Swift (1) The Real Secrets (1) The Real Secrets To Success (1) Time (1) Transformation Success (1) Twitter Profile Verified (1) Type at home (1) Typing Simple Data Entry (1) UID (1) UIDAI (1) UNDRESS ME (1) Ultimate Like a Boss Compilation 2015 (1) Unique Identification Authority of India (1) Vip Bookmark (1) Water Painting (1) Wealthy (1) Wealthy Man (1) Wealthy Men (1) Wealthy Men Dating (1) Web Visit (1) Western Digital (1) Western Digital India (1) ath (1) backlink (1) business card (1) business growth (1) business opportunity (1) buy Facebook like (1) buy Blogger Website (1) career advancement (1) career success (1) careers (1) careet (1) chicago dating (1) click to protect (1) coaching (1) conference (1) control your laughter (1) custom domain (1) desis (1) directory submission seo marketer (1) duplicating (1) ebook (1) effective (1) effective learning (1) elevator pitch (1) employment (1) enterprise (1) fednet toll free (1) friendship (1) google plus followers (1) home (1) home based business (1) home business (1) homebased business (1) information (1) interviewing (1) job offers (1) job search (1) joint ventures (1) kiss (1) letter of recommendation (1) letter of reference (1) letter writing (1) list of general insurance companies (1) marketing strategies (1) mentoring (1) mlm business (1) mlm business opportunity (1) mlm home business (1) mlm lead (1) mlm network marketing (1) mlm opportunity (1) networking on the internet (1) networking while finding a job (1) networkmarketing (1) networks (1) off optimization seo (1) online business (1) pNewsarty rock anthem (1) personal success (1) personalised profiles (1) profit (1) promotion (1) relationship (1) relationship building (1) residual (1) residual income (1) sales skills (1) sell Blogger Website (1) seoclerks.com (1) simplify (1) small business (1) social networking (1) steve jobs biographie (1) steve jobs biographie livre (1) steve jobs film (1) steve jobs histoire (1) steve jobs histoire de la pomme (1) strangers (1) trust (1) twitter follower (1) values (1) what do you do (1) work at home (1) work at home business opportunity mlm (1) young adults (1) youtube views (1) ‎ Bookmarking Sites (1)

Post Top Ad

Responsive Ads Here